My Daughter Begged Me Not to Send Her Back to School. Then Dyslexia Took Birthday Parties, Too.
Academic anxiety and learning differences: our family’s homeschooling story, my daughter’s courage, and the heart behind My Learning Farm in Penryn, California.

After Christmas break in first grade, my daughter Ava begged me not to send her back to school. She asked me to homeschool her. She pleaded not to go. This was the same little girl who loved her friends, who seemed happy to be part of her classroom, and who asked me to volunteer and read stories. She was also the little girl who locked herself in the car in the school parking lot, hid her backpack when it was time for homework, and had an upset tummy before school.
Halfway through first grade, we started homeschooling. We started in trauma, trying to understand why school had become so painful for a child who wanted to learn, loved her friends, and deserved to feel safe. In the years that followed, anxiety reached into testing, learning, and even birthday parties.
For families navigating dyslexia, dysgraphia, dyscalculia, and other learning differences, academic anxiety can become part of everyday life. It can show up before school, during homework, or in an unexpected moment when someone asks a child to read aloud. Our family knows how far that fear can reach.

When my first grader begged not to return to school
I had tried to get Ava evaluated. I wrote a letter asking for testing. Her principal handed it back and told me that school policy was not to test until fourth grade.
I know now that a blanket policy requiring children to wait until fourth grade conflicts with schools’ responsibilities under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, or IDEA. Schools must identify and evaluate children suspected of having disabilities who may need special education. Parents can request an evaluation at any time. If a school refuses, it must provide the required written notice explaining its decision. Handing back a parent’s letter and pointing to a grade-level rule is not an appropriate response.
But back then, I was a mom trying to get someone to listen. I remember the principal standing outside our car in the morning, visibly uncomfortable and, to me, impatient as we waited for Ava to get out. Eventually, I would walk her to her classroom with her little hand in mine.
Inside that car was my frightened child. Outside was the expectation that she would somehow pull herself together and walk into the place that felt so overwhelming. Those mornings were a nightmare.
When she begged me not to return after Christmas break, I listened. I understood that something deeper was happening, and we stepped away. We began learning together: Ava working on reading, and me learning about learning differences and the evidence-based instruction that could help her.

When dyslexia affected birthday parties, too
After her ninth birthday, Ava stopped wanting birthday parties. At that party, someone who I have no doubt meant well had asked her to read their birthday card aloud in front of her guests. Something that might seem small to another person became the reason she did not want another party.
I still ache thinking about it. Her birthday. Her friends. A card someone had brought to celebrate her. Suddenly, there was an unexpected request to read in front of everyone.
This is part of what I want people to understand about learning differences: the impact can reach far beyond assignments and report cards. It can change whether a child wants to participate in something they might otherwise enjoy.
For Ava, it reached into the way she wanted to celebrate her birthday.
Later, there was extreme testing anxiety, too. Changing where she learned had not erased the fear connected to being asked to demonstrate what she could do.

“It started in TK”: the anxiety I hadn’t seen
Recently, Ava and I had an honest conversation about anxiety. I asked her what her first memory of it was. Her answer broke my heart: transitional kindergarten, or TK.
She remembered literacy stations, new routines, new tasks, and not knowing what to expect. The activities felt challenging. She described that as the time she first began to feel that she learned differently.
I thought back to the little girl who seemed so happy to go to school and be with her friends. Both things had been true. She could love her friends and feel afraid of the learning tasks waiting for her.
I remembered how often she asked me to volunteer, especially to come read to her class. I thought she loved the stories, the silly voices, the props, and having her mom there. Now I understand there was more to those requests. She was also looking for comfort, for something familiar, for me. I wish I had understood that then.
What does academic anxiety look like in children with learning differences?
Academic anxiety is worry or distress connected to learning tasks, schoolwork, tests, or situations where a child expects their skills to be judged. It can occur with or without a diagnosed anxiety disorder. For a child with dyslexia, reading aloud may feel frightening. For a child with dysgraphia, a writing assignment may mean struggling to put wonderful ideas onto paper. For a child with dyscalculia, math tasks may bring back memories of confusion and repeated difficulty.
Parents may notice stomachaches before school, headaches around homework time, hidden assignments, repeated delays, or constant requests for reassurance. Some children cry or become angry. Others go quiet, freeze during tests, or say things like “I’m stupid” and “Everyone else gets it.” Some begin avoiding activities where reading, writing, or math might happen unexpectedly.
These behaviors deserve curiosity and care. They do not, by themselves, establish an anxiety disorder or a learning disability. Physical symptoms also deserve medical attention rather than an automatic assumption that they are anxiety. The National Institute of Mental Health identifies persistent worry, irritability, unexplained stomachaches or headaches, and academic struggles among reasons children may benefit from professional evaluation.
For Ava, the hidden backpack, the locked car door, and the pleas not to return to school were signs of distress. So was giving up birthday parties.

Learning disabilities and anxiety: what the research tells us
Learning disabilities can coexist with anxiety, ADHD, depression, and other conditions. Researchers use the word “comorbidity” to describe conditions that occur together. Rates vary depending on the population studied and whether researchers use screening questionnaires or clinical evaluations.
A review of 58 studies found that school-age students with learning disabilities had higher anxiety symptoms, on average, than peers without learning disabilities. The average difference was moderate. Nelson and Harwood’s Learning Disabilities and Anxiety: A Meta-Analysis measured differences in anxiety scores; it did not establish a single percentage of children with diagnosed anxiety disorders.
In a German study of 3,014 third- and fourth-grade children, the subgroup identified with specific learning disorders had questionnaire-based rates of approximately 21% for anxiety, 28% for depression, and 28% for ADHD. These findings came from parent questionnaires and should not be treated as equivalent to independently confirmed clinical diagnoses. The study, Comorbidities Between Specific Learning Disorders and Psychopathology in Elementary School Children in Germany, examined difficulties in reading, spelling, and arithmetic.
The International Dyslexia Association also reports that about 30% of people with dyslexia have coexisting ADHD. Dyslexia and ADHD are distinct conditions, and a child may need support for both.
Math-related anxiety deserves attention as well. Barroso and colleagues’ A Meta-Analysis of the Relation Between Math Anxiety and Math Achievement, covering 223 studies, found that greater math anxiety was associated with lower math achievement. Math anxiety and dyscalculia are different, and this association does not establish that one causes the other.
These findings do not predict an individual child’s future. They do not mean every child with a learning disability will develop anxiety or depression, or that a learning disability alone causes those conditions. They do support paying attention to emotional well-being alongside academic progress.
I care about whether a child is learning to read, write, spell, and understand math. I also care about what that child is beginning to believe about themselves—and what they may be avoiding because they are afraid.
Homeschooling gave us breathing room. Healing took more.
When I describe our experience as academic trauma, I mean the lasting hurt and fear that became connected to school and learning. Homeschooling gave us room to respond differently. We could change the pace, seek instruction that fit, and begin rebuilding trust around learning. There was comfort in familiar routines and breathing room when tasks became hard.
It was the decision our family needed, and it was the beginning of a journey. Ava still struggles with anxiety, including academic anxiety, and she continues to seek professional support. Our story does not end with “we started homeschooling, and everything was fixed.”
There has been growth, joy, and ongoing work. I would gladly take this journey with my children again. If I could bring today’s knowledge back with me, I would do some things differently—and so many things the same.

The courage I see in my daughter
When I look at Ava today, I am so proud of the young woman she is becoming. I see the courage it takes to keep reaching toward things that feel difficult, to try again, to speak honestly about anxiety, and to recognize when she needs help.
Seeking support is something to be proud of. There is strength in saying, “This is hard, and I deserve help.” Watching her learn to advocate for herself means more to me than any grade, test score, or academic milestone ever could.
I wish I could go back and sit beside that little girl at the literacy station. I wish I could make those school mornings feel safe. I wish reading a birthday card had never become something that stood between her and another birthday party. Today, I get to listen to the young woman who can finally tell me what that little girl could not.
Ava, I am proud of you every day, especially on the days you push forward and on the days you recognize that you need rest, reassurance, or another hand to hold. You never have to earn that pride by overcoming one more hard thing.

Why I built My Learning Farm
I see pieces of this story in so many children I work with. Sometimes they arrive with words for their worries. Sometimes they arrive with avoidance, frustration, silence, or a quick “I don’t know” before they have even tried. I try to remember that there may be a whole history sitting beside that child at the table.
Here at My Learning Farm in Penryn, California, I want to offer a safe, loving landing spot. A place where children can ask questions, make mistakes, receive evidence-based instruction that meets their needs, and experience the joy of understanding something that once felt impossible.

My work supporting reading, writing, spelling, and math is rooted in compassion as well as instruction. That means clear expectations, patience, time to build trust, and opportunities to experience progress. It also means recognizing when a child needs professional mental-health care alongside educational support.
I want to be a light at the end of some lonely tunnels, especially for children who do not yet have the vocabulary to explain how frightening learning has felt.
Support for families facing academic anxiety
If you recognize your child here, please take what you are seeing seriously. Write down when the distress happens and what tasks or situations surround it. Ask gentle, specific questions: “Which part feels hardest?” “What are you worried might happen?” “What would help you feel more comfortable?”
Share those observations with their teacher and appropriate health professionals. If you suspect a disability, put your evaluation request in writing and keep a copy. You do not have to wait until fourth grade to raise concerns or request an evaluation.
If you are considering homeschooling—or already homeschooling and finding that fear has followed your child home—my homeschool consultations at My Learning Farm offer personalized guidance with curriculum, pacing, educational priorities, and a more manageable learning day. I support families in Penryn and the surrounding Placer County community as they consider what educational support makes sense for their children.
My children have shaped my career. More importantly, they have shaped my heart. Starting My Learning Farm—and showing up with compassion, love, joy, and support every day since—is my love letter to them.
Their experiences are part of every lesson I plan, every worried parent I listen to, and every child I hope will leave feeling a little more understood.
With love,Ms. SaraMy Learning Farm — Where learning grows.




Comments